The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria

  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon

Toronto, Canada

thefourthmaninthefirepizzeria.com
Pizza restaurant· Dessert restaurant

The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria Reviews | Rating 4.5 out of 5 stars (5 reviews)

The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria is located in Toronto, Canada on 832 Dundas St W. The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria is rated 4.5 out of 5 in the category pizza restaurant in Canada.

Address

832 Dundas St W

Phone

+1 4167923473

Service options

Outdoor seatingDeliveryTakeawayDine-in

Amenities

Toilets

Open hours

Mon
Closed
Tue
12–9:30PM
Wed
12–9:30PM
Thu
12–9:30PM
Fri
12–10:30PM
Sat
12–10:30PM
Sun
12–9:30PM

...
Write review Claim Profile

R

Rebecca O'Gorman

I came here for the first time this week with my friend. We were quoted a 30 minute wait for our food, but it took about 40-45 minutes. We didn’t mind waiting, but what grossed us out was we noticed that none of the back of house staff were wearing either gloves or masks. And to make things worse, while one man was making a salad, he was popping food into his mouth as he was working. Then, he would step away and go on his phone, and then go back to preparing food while snacking- with no gloves or mask on, and I’m pretty sure he didn’t wash his hands either... anyway, 2 stars cause the food was really amazing! But I was super paranoid while eating it because of what I saw and will not be coming back.

K

Kimberly Simmons

The ordering at the window was easy with the service provided. We got a pepperoni slice to share as we were eating on the go. The slice tasted like it just got out of the oven. My son just gobbled up his slice in no time. Loved the fresh sauce that was on the pizza. Great location near enough to Trinity Bellwoods and Toronto Western. They were really friendly to my son. He cannot wait until they have ice cream in the summer. Definitely order from here again.

B

Bradford Smith

Made a (window) \Curbside\ walk-up order of a couple slices of C&P around 2:10 in the afternoon last Sunday, January 25, 2021. We saw the sign on the all green building on the North side of Dundas just East of Trinity Bellwoods Park, and became curious. The girl working was pleasant enough, more business than kindness but thats the job. They had very tasty, what I presume was \wood-fired\ pizza. The sauce had visible pieces of tomato in it, and the crust was incredible. Enough crisp and just a light amount of charring. All the ingredients tasted fresh. The pizza was exactly as I expected it would be. They accept cash or credit/debit. The prices were slightly higher than average. You should visit this place if you like good (thinner) crust pizza. Will absolutely return.

J

Joel Tiefenbach

The Brooklyn Squares remind me of a Pizza Hut pizza from 25yrs ago that probably wasn't as good as this is but it hits the spot in the same way. The sauce is nice and tangy and the gooey cheese goes perfectly with a crunchy bottom and chewy middle. If you're looking for a break from the wannabe Napolitana places popping up every block I'd recommend this joint.

J

Jeffrey Ng

One of the best pizza joints in the city. Generous toppings and perfect amount of sauce. Yummy crust.